Uncategorized

Looking at Magic Formula returns, Morningstar gets all apologetic over industry performance

close

Email a Friend

Screening 2.0 and beyond

Readers of this site have learned a bit about Screening 2.0 — the ability to use Internet tools (many of them, free) to recreate portfolios that conform to the investment criteria of history’s best investors.

Validea’s John Reese has done much of the research legwork on the subject and has produced a premium product to help investors create Peter Lynch, Ken Fisher, and Ben Graham portfolios (among others).

The magic of  Greenblatt’s Magic Formulamagictrick

One source I mention frequently is Joel Greenblatt’s Magic Formula.  Greenblatt wrote about his investing magic in The Little Book that Beats the Market.  He also provides investors with a free website to screen for the top ranking stocks that fit his criteria at magicformulainvesting.com.

Morningstar takes a look at Magic Formula returns in a recent piece.  Here’s what they come up with:

We see that the formula posted approximately a 19.9% annualized return from the beginning of 1988 through Sept. 30, 2009. Over that time, the S&P 500 Index returned 9.4% annualized.

Not too shabby.

But as a frequent shill for the mutual fund industry, Morningstar feels the need to compare this market-trumping return to top performing mutual funds.  And that’s when things take an interesting turn:  The article’s author, John Coumarianos, sounds surprisingly introspective in his (near) critique of active fund management.

The market isn’t efficient, as the indexers say, but its inefficiencies are apparently not easily exploitable for some of the finest pros either–at least given how many of them currently go about investing, trying earnestly to predict future profits and discounting them back to the present. Perhaps managers outthink themselves or have too much confidence in their predictive abilities instead of relying on past results.

Why funds may perform so badly as a class

The author also cites the mutual fund structure, size, and the legacy nature of a fund portfolio — making it so easy for investors to buy and sell an already outdated model — as an impediment.  Does this mean that portfolio mirroring a la kaChing and Covestor (where investors sync their brokerage accounts up to a professional investor’s portfolio model) has another leg up on the industry?  The separately managed account model (SMA) which institutionalizes this mirroring process does have its benefits, including better tax efficiency (all stocks are held in investor’s name and cost basis is individualized) and transparency (stocks in the portfolio are held in brokerage account).

0 comments on “Looking at Magic Formula returns, Morningstar gets all apologetic over industry performance”

Outlier OpinionsMakers

Uncategorized

Rebranding rebirth: Netspend and Rêv come together to form Ouro

  • Prepaid card provider, Netspend, and Rêv, a digital payment technology provider, recently integrated under a new brand called Ouro.
  • The new brand tells the story of rebirths as the Sosa brothers return to Netspend, a company they founded out of their apartment in 1999.
Rabab Ahsan | November 20, 2023
Uncategorized

The Daily Tearsheet: A day in the life of Kristen Anderson, the CEO and co-founder of Catch

  • In this daily, we've got a day in the life of Kristen Anderson, the CEO and co-founder of Catch
  • And in other news, NFTs continue to spread.
Rivka Abramson | May 03, 2022
Uncategorized

Job Opening: People Person

  • Tearsheet is growing and looking to hire a People Person.
  • You'll help us source and grow new talent for our team.
Tearsheet Editors | December 09, 2021
Uncategorized

Job Opening: Audio-Visual Editor

  • Tearsheet's podcasts, webinars, and conferences are industry favorites.
  • We're looking for a ninja editor to take our audio/visual content to the next level.
Arifah Esar | January 01, 2021
Uncategorized

Careers at Tearsheet – Journalist

  • Tearsheet is an impactful media organization, helping its audience understand the impact technology has on financial services.
  • We're always looking for great writing talent to add to our team and organization.
Aaron Singer | January 01, 2021
More Articles