Online Lenders

Goldman Sachs’ Marcus is winning the personal loans arms race

  • Online lenders launched almost 10 years before Marcus, but the one-year-old Goldman Sachs sub-brand has had a head start all along
  • As online lenders struggle to stay profitable, Marcus is pushing an us-versus-them anti-fee campaign highlighting potentially predatory practices of online lenders like Lending Club
close

Email a Friend

Goldman Sachs’ Marcus is winning the personal loans arms race

Marcus by Goldman Sachs said it was going to lend $2 billion to customers by the end of this year. As of late Monday, it had already done that.

The announcement follows a gloomy earnings season for online lending companies, whose personal loans rival Marcus’. Lending Club has reported losses exceeding $200 million over the last six quarters; Prosper has lost $210 million since the start of 2016, despite various cost-cutting measures, and lost its unicorn status. Even OnDeck Capital, which focuses on small businesses, is struggling to become profitable, having reported losses over eight consecutive quarters.

On top of it, the Cleveland Federal Reserve Bank laid into such companies in a report Thursday, calling “peer-to-peer” lending a “predatory” business requiring more regulation; though it has since admitted its data sample doesn’t distinctively separate different types of online lenders.

Even though Goldman launched Marcus about a decade after online lenders emerged, Marcus has had a head start in the personal loans race all along. The Lending Clubs of the world addressed a need when people couldn’t get access to loans from traditional banks following the financial crisis; they were technology companies invading the financial sector promising access to loans and a better, faster customer experience for higher rates and more fees.

But for Goldman, it’s taken a fraction of the time to set up a sub-brand and begin accepting customer deposits from everyday customers. And that’s not just to rival JPMorgan, Citi or Wells Fargo, but to challenge “new” consumer lenders. (Earlier this month, however, it announced its online-only consumer deposits business, currently branded GS Bank, will be folded into Marcus by the end of the year.) Marcus passed $1 billion in loans this summer.

Online lending companies match borrowers with investors and tout faster approvals and access to credit for people who have difficulty getting it from traditional financial institutions. According to the Fed, however, borrowers don’t use the loans to refinance pre-existing loans, credit scores go down for years after borrowing from an online lender and the loans don’t actually go to those underserved by traditional banks. Marcus, which offers personal loans to consumers between $3,500 and $30,000, has obvious advantages over its Silicon Valley competitors: a household name brand like Goldman Sachs behind it, the ability to raise FDIC-insured deposits as a deposit-taking institution and deep relationships with institutional investors that purchase consumer loans — like Goldman Sachs, which helps fund Prosper loans and is effectively competing with its own customer.

Goldman sees a $13 billion lending opportunity with Marcus over three years, CFO Marty Chavez said Tuesday in remarks at the Bank of America Merrill Lynch Future of Financials Conference.

All year, Marcus has been marketing itself as the Goldman Sachs offshoot that’s more relatable to the masses. Its first campaign focused on de-stigmatizing debt, one of the most personal and sensitive topics for people. Since late October, it’s been pushing an anti-fee campaign scripted to show how frequently and commonly people accept fees without fully understanding why the fee structure is in place in the first place and perhaps even highlight the fee structures at competing companies; namely, Lending Club, one of the largest players in online lending with more fees in place than its peers.

“Don’t Get Fee’d is a big part of our new campaign to create awareness,” said Dustin Cohn, Marcus’ chief marketing officer, at a recent event unveiling the campaign. “Once you understand personal loans can be a better option for you, [you see] many other lenders charge fees — origination fees, late fees, fees for paying down your loan early.”

Marcus was built with and for Main Street customers — a new customer set for the global investment bank — on the pillars of value, transparency, simplicity and the ability to customize. Specifically, that means charging no fees ever, giving customers the ability to choose monthly payment amounts and select payment dates upfront and change them as well as an automated, jargon-free online application, according to Cohn.

The biggest change to the online lending industry since it first boomed is the increased customer expectation for transparency, according to Craig Schleicher, a senior manager in PwC’s consumer finance group.

“A no-fees option is designed to minimize consumer surprises around origination, late fees and other fees they might not expect,” he said, not addressing Marcus specifically. “Customers really value knowing exactly what their financial commitment is through the life of the loan.”

0 comments on “Goldman Sachs’ Marcus is winning the personal loans arms race”

Member Exclusive, Online Lenders

Mission Lane’s approach to helping people access credit with Shane Holdaway

  • Shane Holdaway spent close to two decades working in large traditional financial institutions.
  • As CEO of Mission Lane, he's serving a million customers that banks tend to overlook.
Zachary Miller | July 30, 2021
Member Exclusive, Online Lenders

How Shopify is creating an ‘embedded finance ecosystem’ with Shopify Capital

  • Shopify merchants benefit from a quick, simple application and approval process.
  • Shopify is slowly building an arsenal of finance solutions to better serve its users.
Shehzil Zahid | June 10, 2021
Member Exclusive, Online Lenders

‘Fix the errors and a lot more people will flow through the system’: The credit ecosystem may need a makeover

  • Credit invisibility is still very much alive in the U.S.
  • But it may not be just one problem within the system that’s causing the mess. Rather, it could be the whole system.
Rivka Abramson | June 07, 2021
Member Exclusive, Online Lenders

Through software, Drummond Community Bank moves into personal and auto lending

  • The bank will provide its customers with AI-powered personal and auto loans.
  • AI-based lending platforms can give community banks a competitive advantage over larger banks.
Ismail Umar | May 10, 2021
Member Exclusive, Online Lenders

With the cannabis market set to double, lenders hope to capitalize on the opportunity

  • Financing in the space typically has come in the form of equity investments.
  • Federal deregulation would give more lending options to cannabis businesses.
Shehzil Zahid | May 05, 2021
More Articles