Online Lenders

Are we in an online lending bubble?

  • Online lenders are setting origination records.
  • Are things overheating?
close

Email a Friend

Are we in an online lending bubble?

We’re in an interesting time in online lending. After years of fits and starts and boatloads of money flowing into the sector, record originations are being set all over the industry. We recently explored online lending trends going into 2019 and what participants in the sector are expecting in the near future.

Both consumer and business lenders are tracking strongly:

Last week, LendingClub released its third quarter earnings results, and saw a record number of originations – in the quarter alone, totaling $2.9 billion, representing an 18% improvement compared to the same quarter last year. “What this tells us about the industry as a whole is that the demand and desire for alternative lending services continues to remain strong,” Jessie Szymanski, head of institutional investor strategy for LendingClub, told Tearsheet via email.

While personal loans have surged to a record as the fastest-growing U.S. consumer-lending category, according to data from credit bureau TransUnion, it’s fintech firms that are driving a lot of that growth.

fintech driving consumer loan growth

 

Digital and fintech lenders originated more than a third of total personal loans in 2017 compared with less than 1 percent in 2010.

But inside all the congratulatory back-patting, it appears that things might be overheating. Goldman Sachs, which has aggressively expanded in the digital banking and lending space with its Marcus offering, explained that it would be dialing things down a bit, according to Bloomberg.

Anonymous sources inside Goldman Sachs told Bloomberg that the dampened expectations have to do with a concern about the credit cycle. It’s just as likely, though, that Marcus, without any history of running a consumer loan portfolio, is getting antsy about its internal acquisition metrics. In a market with almost infinite demand for credit, it’s very easy to expand — a lender just needs to relax its credit scoring criteria. Perhaps Marcus sees something that says it’s growing its customer base and lending portfolio too quickly.

There are conflicting forces at work affecting customer acquisitions costs. As more businesses and individuals become aware of online lending alternatives, this expands the target market for online lenders. But, at the same time, more money is flowing to advertising new lending options. And as this money filters down to customer acquisition channels, it can drive up the cost of acquisition. SoFi appears to be paying $756 to acquire a new customer. And Fast Company reports that Lending Club and Prosper typically spend $350-$450 to bring in a new borrower.

Acquisition costs typically spike when young online lenders raise their first big funding rounds and they begin to put that money to work in marketing. Those costs then can settle down as these firms garner the necessary expertise to efficiently deploy this capital. But if acquisition costs continue to rise, many of the smaller, less-capitalized lenders may find themselves left behind, as only the largest firms will be able to afford to bring in new customers.

0 comments on “Are we in an online lending bubble?”

Online Lenders, Podcasts

Zest AI’s Mike de Vere: ‘You don’t have to give up economics to be more fair’

  • Machine learning and AI models are changing the face of lending.
  • They're able to clarify the tradeoffs between fairness and economics and optimize them.
Zachary Miller | September 08, 2020
Online Lenders

How Fiserv’s partnership with VMware enabled it to launch a PPP application in 8 days

  • Time was of the essence for SMBs when the Cares Act was announced.
  • The two companies stood up a PPP app that was responsible for distributing $1.4 billion in PPP loans.
Zachary Miller | September 04, 2020
Online Lenders

‘No knee-jerk reactions’: How LendUp quickly adapted to be resilient during the pandemic

  • Anu Shultes is a cancer survivor with 25 years experience in financial services.
  • She brings her own personal resilience to the challenges her firm faced during the pandemic.
Zachary Miller | August 20, 2020
Online Lenders, Podcasts

Earnest’s David Green on student lending in today’s economic environment

  • The pandemic's impact is being felt on the student lending side.
  • Earnest's chief product officer David Green joins us to discuss how to help students pay for school.
Zachary Miller | July 31, 2020
Online Lenders, Podcasts

Upstart’s Paul Gu: ‘AI is a mindboggling change in the economics of lending’

  • Upstart's lending models have been shown to expand access to capital without taking on more risk.
  • The fintech firm is rolling out a new auto product in addition to a credit decisioning API.
Zachary Miller | July 29, 2020
More Articles