Business of Fintech

‘The market is really crowded’: Anthemis Group’s Jillian Williams on tough times for personal finance apps

  • Personal finance management is probably the most well-known part of consumer fintech, but many platforms are having trouble monetizing their product offerings
  • As the market for PFM becomes more competitive and banks take on more PFM capabilities, the pressure will fall on third-party PFM apps to provide a differentiated offering for the customer
close

Email a Friend

‘The market is really crowded’:  Anthemis Group’s Jillian Williams on tough times for personal finance apps

To many consumers, financial technology is synonymous with the concept of personal finance management, or industry speak for managing one’s spending habits — PFM for short.

It’s a space that started out with Mint ten years ago, with a new way to look at all of one’s finances in one place. The field has now grown to accommodate an ever-expanding number of direct-to-consumer PFM apps, including apps like Digit, Clarity Money, Penny and Qapital, and banks are now folding PFM capabilities into their mobile apps.

To venture capitalists, PFM has become somewhat of an over-hackneyed phrase, with questions looming about how these platforms will generate revenue over the long term.

“I am very wary of ‘basic’ PFM tools that don’t have clear differentiators in the market,” said Ryan Gilbert, a partner at Propel Venture Partners. “Most PFM apps seem to be doing the same things.”

Tearsheet caught up with Jillian Williams, an investment associate at Anthemis, a venture capital firm that invests in early-stage technology companies for financial services, about tough times for PFM. The following has been edited for length and clarity.

Banks have been folding in PFM features and competing apps are having trouble differentiating. Where do you see the PFM market right now?
A lot of PFM will continue to move to a business-to-business, or business-to-business-to-consumer model. Things [business-to-consumer PFMs] struggle with are being able to monetize and with customer acquisition.

What’s the problem with business-to-consumer PFM?
The market is really crowded and it’s hard to provide that extra value to really distinguish themselves from other platforms in the space. It’s like a little feature that one has versus the other, but those are features, rather than standalone platforms and they’re not really defensible on their own. Consumers are fickle, and if you’re not providing them with extra value or some sort of insights the first couple of times, they just move on. PFM companies have struggled to monetize no matter how much these customers enjoy it — take Digit for example: when they started to charge people, despite how much people loved the platform, that’s when customers started to move away.

So banks will take on PFM where startups can’t?
[For banks], PFM can give you insights into how you’re spending your money and can change the way consumers view banks. Putting [mobile banking and PFM] together can benefit banks with more insights into where customers’ priorities are in terms of savings goals.

If PFM is such a difficult business model, why do VCs still fund them?
One reason they could still be funding them is that the business-to-consumer space in fintech does have a huge opportunity, and in most technology sectors, that’s the most sexy space that you want to be in. PFM is the most notable space. For example, most people you speak to will know what Mint is.

So VCs are swept up in the romantic idea of being able to give more people access to financial services, and PFM is a way to do that?
I would agree with that you, but I see VCs moving away from it a lot more. There is that idea that there’s an opportunity to improve inclusion and awareness. Some investments have persisted, especially when you find someone has this different edge.

Could robo-advisers start taking on PFM capabilities?
You see a lot of robo-advisers not becoming PFM platforms, but becoming all-in-one solutions to see all of your finances.

What’s next?
I could see some consolidations, and a lot of pivoting, and some will probably shut down. It’s becoming a crowded space that’s unsustainable. I don’t think [PFM] is going to collapse, but there’s not much room for new entrants. I think there’s definitely room for some [PFMs] in market to grow, but it’s not a market where there’s much opportunity for new entrants unless there’s a really new hook.

0 comments on “‘The market is really crowded’: Anthemis Group’s Jillian Williams on tough times for personal finance apps”

Business of Fintech

Q1 fintech earnings: stocks in the red, but growth prospects abound

  • Fintech stocks continue to dive in public markets as macroeconomic trends weighed on companies' first quarter earnings, which came in below equity analysts' expectations.
  • We look at four major fintech players that reported their results – PayPal, Square, Robinhood and LendingClub – and outline the major takeaways from their Q1 earnings reports.
Iulia Ciutina | May 09, 2022
Business of Fintech, Member Exclusive

Fintech valuations seriously challenged after a booming 2021

  • Private and public markets are taking a more cautious approach towards valuing fintechs, as the recent market sell-off coupled with macro headwinds are raising concerns.
  • This comes in contrast with the optimism displayed last year, which saw record numbers of capital pouring in the fintech sector, and wave of fintechs going public.
Iulia Ciutina | March 23, 2022
Business of Fintech, Online Lenders

‘Change is hard for banks’: Behind Amount’s acquisition of Linear

  • Amount, a banking technology provider offering account opening, loan origination and BNPL financing solutions, is acquiring SMB loan and account origination platform Linear for $175 million.
  • The acquisition complements Amount’s consumer banking solutions with Linear’s technology for the commercial segment.
Iulia Ciutina | March 02, 2022
Business of Fintech, Finance Everywhere

‘The industry believes that poor credit scores are self–inflicted’: A new wave of fintechs is giving the underbanked access to credit

  • New fintechs are targeting underserved communities that don’t have credit histories, using new methodologies to help them build credit scores.
  • As more Millennials and Gen Zers navigate their financial journeys, their participation in the credit system could increasingly be aided by such fintechs.
Iulia Ciutina | January 26, 2022
Business of Fintech, Online Lenders

From one idea to 2 million applications: TomoCredit wants to change the credit score game

  • As an immigrant, TomoCredit founder and CEO Kristy Kim wanted to develop a solution to the problem of credit accessibility in the US.
  • At first she wanted to license an underwriting solution to big banks, but that would have taken too long - so she decided to launch a credit card company.
Iulia Ciutina | January 24, 2022
More Articles