[podcast] Why Foundation Capital’s Charles Moldow invests in B2C fintech companies

charles moldow investing in fintech
Charles Moldow, Foundation Capital
Charles Moldow, Foundation Capital

Last week, we had Caribou Honig of QED Investors on the podcast and I said that his portfolio is one of the strongest in fintech. If I had to name the top investors in the next generation of finance companies, Charles Moldow of Foundation Capital  would definitely be near the top of the list, as well. Charles joins us this week on the Tradestreaming Podcast to talk about his thesis behind why he likes to invest in a trillion dollar industry that, in his words, “doesn’t do a great job servicing its customer base”.

His white paper, A Trillion Dollar Market By the People, For the People is essential reading for anyone who wants to know about the marketplace lending space:  its size, structure, and potential. We’ll include a link in the show notes to it. His current portfolio includes auxmoney, BTCJam, Finxera (formerly Bancbox), LendingClub [IPO 12/11/14], Lending Home, Motif Investing, and On Deck Capital [IPO 12/17/14].

I think you’ll find my conversation with Charles to be thought-provoking — pay attention to why he prefers to build standalone B2C finance companies as opposed to firms that partner and sell into incumbent financial institutions. Contrarian and a very interesting point.

Listen to the FULL episode

In this episode, Charles shares:

  • his thesis on why he likes to invest in early stage fintech
  • why fintech has been relatively off the radar screen for many venture capitalists
  • his preference building B2C companies in the financial services space and why B2B firms have a hard go at it
  • how his white paper changed how we view peer to peer lending by renaming it the marketplace lending industry
  • why he turned down investing in Lending Club when he first met them in 2009 and why pulled the trigger in 2010 and invested
  • the struggles of matching supply and demand for a consumer financial marketplace
  • the challenges originally faced by OnDeck Capital and how the company solved them
  • the opportunity to market to millennials and the challenge the generation (with rising debt and weak wages) poses for financial firms
  • his view on the heating up of valuations in the fintech space
  • his firm’s interest in insurance and why it could be an exciting, investable space

More Resources

EVEN MORE RESOURCES

[podcast] QED Investors’ Caribou Honig on investing in today’s early stage fintech

fintech VC, QED Investors' Caribou Honig

Our guest for this episode is Caribou Honig, a founding partner of QED Investors. QED has quietly become one of the top investors in the financial technology space — their investment portfolio includes early big successes like SoFi and Prosper and also firms like LendUp, borro, Orchard, Avant Credit, blooom, and ApplePie Capital.

Caribou Honig, QED Investors
Caribou Honig, QED Investors

As part of our conversation, Caribou shares his personal path to how he ended up as part of the founding team of QED after a post-MBA career at Capital One where he developed a passion for data-driven marketing,, including responsibility for a $50 mm marketing budget, management of a 200 person underwriting operation, and cracking the code on digital credit card origination. This experience, along with his co-founders which include the founder of Capital One, provides a differentiator for the investment firm when it comes to deal flow and portfolio building.

In this episode, Caribou shares his views on:

  • his background running data-driven marketing at CapitalOne and how this impacts his firm’s approach to investing in early stage fintech
  • why “data-first” strategies are more likely to win
  • hist team’s 150 years of experience in consumer lending market and why it’s such an exciting sector right now
  • current trends in the financial technology space
  • how incumbent financial institutions view startups in the space
  • how these larger financial firms are planning for their futures
  • QED’s investment mandate and the types of fintech companies that fit well into the investment firm’s sweet spot
  • the companies in his portfolio and the investment thesis behind them
  • lastly, we’ll talk about where Caribou is looking to make investments in the future.

Listen to the FULL episode

More Resources

EVEN MORE RESOURCES

Fintech investor, Pascal Bouvier on where there’s big money to be made in fintech

Pascal Bouvier on fintech investing

Pascal Bouvier is an experienced fintech investor and joins Tradestreaming today to talk about his investments in the fintech space, how the market has changed over the past few years, and where this investor thinks the opportunities lie ahead. Follow Pascal on Twitter, LinkedIn, and his blog.

Who are you and what do you do?

Pascal Bouvier, fintech investor
Pascal Bouvier, fintech investor

I am a fintech investor who brings both operational and investment experience to the table. I have worked with large financial institutions as well as with startups and post-revenue small-sized businesses. I have also worked with technology and non-technology businesses. This uniquely positions me as an investor in early stage companies in the financial services industry.  Further, I do have a global background having worked on several continents, a requirement given the financial services industry is a truly global industry.

What’s your view of fintech and finserv and how has it changed?

I have developed an expansive model where finserv equals fintech, like it or not. By that, I mean all finserv participants will have to behave like technology companies going forward. This means they will have to stop creating products and pushing them in unilateral ways to consumers and users and they will have to start to focus on technology, data and in a broad sense, customer experience.

All participants will have to do so, whether they are startups or incumbents, large or small or service providers. This will have, and is already having, a profound impact on how the industry is organizing itself. Namely, the customer and his needs – be it an individual or a corporation – will need to be front and center as opposed to wha the financial institution thinks the customer needs. This is both a subtle and profound departure from past and current paradigms.

In many ways the industry will have to reorganize itself around customers’ lifetime events via contextually relevant services and move away from a product-centric approach. That is the greatest insight one can have as a fintech investor.

You have a very interesting work history, with experience on the operator side in software and other industries. How has this impacted your worldview of fintech as an investor?

I was a commercial banker which influenced my view on commercial credit. I worked as an operator with various early stage startups, as well as high growth post revenue SMBs, which helped me understand the reality of day to day tactical operations and long term strategic vision in a very material and tangible way.

I also have acted as an investor in the banking world and in the VC world. My fintech investment style has been heavily influenced by my learnings as an operator. Early stage investing is not purely informed by dry analysis and spreadsheets. It is informed by how one relates to individuals and teams and by how one understands how operational complexity grows as a startup grows and experiences traction. I believe this has made me a better investor.

Where’s your sweet spot for making an investment? What does your target investment look like?

Based on how I see the financial services industry evolving, I believe the most effective sweet spot at this point in time is to focus on seed, Series A, and Series B investments where the investment size ranges from $500k to up to $5m. I do like to go above $5m for exceptional investments. I like that flexibility.

From an operational point of view, this means I focus on startups that have a product or platform in use with customers, whether in beta or whether live, and whether pre revenue or post. I shy away from ideas or technology that has yet been productized. I focus on companies that are about to hit product/market fit or already have a strong sense of product/market fit and who are experiencing the first inklings of pipeline growth. Although my view is global in nature, I have lately focused on Europe and the US.

How do you compare consumer fintech opportunities with more B2B ones?

Speaking of the firm I recently left, the portfolio is evenly split between D2C and B2B. some of the D2C are really B2B2C plays.  As for my natural inclination, it really depends on the sector I look at.

The industry is comprised of five sectors: lending, capital markets, insurance, asset management, and payments. Given a particular geography and time for each of these sectors, I would be more attracted to D2C models, whereas this may change to B2B models otherwise. For payments, I prefer B2B by far, as getting traction in D2C payments is extremely difficult. In banking and insurance, I would prefer digitizing distribution channels which may mean D2C or B2B2C. For asset management or capital markets I would favor B2B models.

It really depends. Consumer plays are so much more difficult to hit just right that there is a natural comfort zone around B2B models, in my opinion.

What do you think is the most exciting investable part of fintech right now?

I will give several answers. First, insurance because the industry has barely been touched as of yet by disruption, so the opportunity is immense. Second, anything that has to do with identity management as applied to any of the five sectors comprising the industry. Third, and this is a new trend I am focusing much more on these days, financial wellness, which can be equally applied to the Western world as to emerging markets. Financial wellness is going to be huge in my opinion, as it sits at the intersection of the expectations of customers and a better stewardship of money, in general (not that I expect us to be completely weened from excessive consumerism mind you, but still I do expect changing times ahead).

What’s the most overdone part of fintech? Where are expectations too high in fintech investing?

It is always difficult to answer this question. So much depends on geography and timing. I would tend to answer that retail/consumer payments in the US is overheated and extremely crowded. “Digital” banking also seems to fall in that category. Finally, one particular model past its prime is pure retail roboadvisory in the wealth management space.

Startup Roundup: Marketplace lending up big, blockchain getting a lot of attention

fintech startups shaking things up

[alert type=white ]Every week, we write about fintech startups raising money, making partnerships, and generally disrupting finance.[/alert]

Wow, what a week.

Money 2020 has turned into a must-attend fintech event. Equity crowdfunding rules were announced on Friday –  creating utter chaos for some players and elation for others. Things are speeding up in fintech land as stock market holder ICE bought leading data provider IDC in a deal worth over $5B.

For more fintech coverage during the week, you’re going to want to connect with Tradestreaming on Facebook. Click here to do following Tradestreaming on Facebook.

OneVest Launches “1000 Angels” to Reinvent Venture Capital (Crowdfund Insider)
Tradestreaming Tearsheet: Onevest, a New York based investment crowdfunding platform focused on funding start-up entities, has announced the launching today of its new “1,000 Angels, the “world’s largest digital-first, invitation-only investor network”.

$1 Billion In Small Business Loans From PayPal (PYMNTS.COM)
Tradestreaming Tearsheet: PayPal used to be all about processing payments instead of handling funds, but if you’re not growing in this business, you’re dying. PayPal is serious about growing its SMB loan business and seems to be positioned well to continue attracting new business borrowers.

Can This Startup Restore Privacy in Payments and Turn a Profit? (American Banker)
Tradestreaming Tearsheet: Privacy.com is catching the attention of many finance professionals (including some smart fintech investors) as a creative security platform that’s building its business by protecting transaction privacy. In the Edward Snowden era, it will be interesting to see if the startup can build a business with its revenue model (taking a cut on interchange fees around a transaction).

Bizfi Originates $127M in Financing in Q3 2015 (BusinessWire)
Tradestreaming Tearsheet: Bizfi, a fintech platform that combines aggregation, funding and a participation marketplace for small businesses had a very good quarter, reporting $127M in business financing during Q3 2015.

ReadyForZero launches credit monitoring product (ReadyForZero)
Tradestreaming Tearsheet: Following CreditKarma’s success in providing credit tools, personal finance manager (PFM), ReadyForZero launches its own credit monitoring tool.

Groundfloor Announces Three New Tools to Expand Peer-to-Peer Real Estate Lending (Crowdfund Insider)
Tradestreaming Tearsheet: On Monday during the Money2020 conference, real estate lending marketplace Groundfloor introduced three new analytic tools that allow peer-to-peer real estate investors greater flexibility and analysis over security selection and portfolio management.

Digital Asset Holdings Acquires Blockchain-as-a-Service Innovator, Blockstack.io (Finovate)
Tradestreaming Tearsheet: “Miron Cuperman, Blockstack CTO, called Digital Asset “the best platform” to deliver Blockstack’s blockchain application development tools as part of a comprehensive solution for customers. Digital Asset Holdings CEO Blythe Masters praised both Blockstack’s technology as well as its talent, calling Cuperman “a renowned pioneer in the blockchain world.””

Lending Club Reports Q3 Results. Loan Originations Jump 92% Year-over-Year (Zacks)
Tradestreaming Tearsheet: Lending Club (NYSE: LC), the largest marketplace lending platform in the US, has announced Q3 results. And the origination growth is silencing some of the biggest critics of the first marketplace lender to float on public markets.

Startups raising money this week

Spreedly Raises $2.5 Million in New Funding (Finovate)
Tradestreaming Tearsheet: Spreedly helps marketplaces and platforms accept a wider range of payment types while reducing cost, complexity, and compliance burden.

Zebit Secures $10M investment; Launches Zero-Interest Credit to the Underserved (LetsTalkPayments)
Tradestreaming Tearsheet: The credit can be used to make purchases from the Zebit Market or directly from retailers that accept Zebit as a checkout option.

Issuer processor platform Marqeta closes $25m funding round, new customers (Finextra)
Tradestreaming Tearsheet: At Money20/20 2015, Marqeta, the Open API issuer processor platform, announced a host of new marquee customers, including Affirm, DoorDash, HyperWallet and Kabbage, alongside known customers such as Facebook, Bento for Business and Perk. Marqeta also confirmed closing a $25 million Series C round.