Payments

With debit card, Transferwise moves closer to becoming a bank

  • Transferwise is piloting a cross-border debit card for borderless account customers, letting them withdraw funds in local currency
  • Banks aren't interested in competing products, because the market isn't large enough
With debit card, Transferwise moves closer to becoming a bank

Transferwise, the payments startup that once campaigned on an anti-bank message, launched a “borderless” bank account this week, demonstrating that for financial services companies, all roads eventually lead back to banks.

The company is piloting a Mastercard debit card tied to a “borderless” account from which people can withdraw funds in local currency and hold funds in 28 currencies. In doing so it’s inching closer to bank territory while stopping short of becoming a bank. The debit card product is in a beta phase with 1,000 customers in Europe, but the plan is to roll out the product globally by early next year, said Joe Cross, head of global marketing and public relations at Transferwise.

“We’re not going to apply for banking license, but with the physical card, in theory, it replaces your bank,” he said.

Similarly, SoFi, whose tagline was “Don’t bank, SoFi,” ultimately sought a banking license itself though it has since backtracked on that endeavor because of a company scandal surrounding then-CEO Mike Cagney. No matter what the entry point is — personal loans, payments processing, small business loans — the direction seems to be the same: offering a more diverse suite of financial services products.

Transferwise’s more obvious key competitors in the $429 billion global remittance market are money transfer companies like Western Union and PayPal; like any company, it needs to work with network of partner banks to deliver its product. Banks aren’t likely to launch a competing product because the market is too small and the international wires are a profitable revenue stream.

“Transferwise is coming at [the market] aiming at a problem they’ve identified that is a small part of most banks — the thinking is ‘we can build a product that addresses this problem,’ and it’s not a big part of any bank’s business that they’ll want to come at us,” said David True, partner at PagGility Advisors. 

For now, the international remittance market is the domain of startups. Moreover, international currency transfers generate bank revenue from fees, leaving them with no incentive to compete with startups by launching cross-border debit cards or similar digital transfer services. Apart from what’s seen as limited profitability for banks to launch similar products, rolling out a competing product would be also be hard for banks because of regulatory hurdles.

“Banks wouldn’t do this for two reasons — one is the size of the market they would go after, and banks make a ton of money off of cross-border fees,” said Andrew Luca, a partner at PwC. “There’s really not a lot of incentive for a financial institution to give you products that reduce that fee income.”

Payments

‘Free money has a way of sharing itself’: Dosh’s consumer shopping app enables retailers to target new customers

  • Dosh is a popular ecommerce app which offers cash back to shoppers.
  • Merchants use it as a transaction-based, new form of advertising.
Michael Deleon | August 20, 2019
Member Exclusive, Payments

Research: How popular does Apple Card need to be to generate $1 billion in revenue?

  • For Apple Card to be significant, it will need to produce billions in revenue.
  • We look at what it will take for Apple to get there.
Michael Deleon | August 19, 2019
Payments

For American Express, contactless transit payments may pave the way for broader acceptance of the technology

  • Earlier this summer, the MTA rolled out contactless payments for its riders in New York City.
  • American Express sees this as a harbinger to broad rollout of contactless in the US.
Zack Miller | August 19, 2019
Member Exclusive, Payments

Credit and debit cards also undergo changes in the age of digital finance

  • As financial software evolves, physical credit and debit cards are also changing.
  • From design, orientation, colors, and materials, innovation is also coming to cards.
Sara Toth Stub | August 15, 2019
Payments

Venmo launches instant transfers to US bank accounts

  • Venmo users get added functionality.
  • But more importantly, Venmo is still searching for a road to monetization.
Zoe Murphy | August 13, 2019
More Articles