Payments

How Canadian retailers are waging war on cash

  • Some Canadian retailers are going cashless, a move enabled by the wide adoption of contactless payments.
  • A U.S. retailer that did a cashless trial says going fully cashless would shut out the unbanked and the underbanked.
close

Email a Friend

How Canadian retailers are waging war on cash

When DavidsTea co-founder David Segal launched Mad Radish restaurant in Ottawa, Canada, this summer, the hope was that cashless payments would be part of a better customer experience.

“Great brands are built by customer evangelists,” said Segal, who left DavidsTea last year. “Offering a cashless checkout process is just one of the ways we’re working to create that unique experience.”

Retailers see winning the war on cash as a way to differentiate themselves. Banks and fintech companies have gotten behind the idea, too. But Segal’s vision of being able to pay for things without cash is partly enabled by aspects of the Canadian payments ecosystem. Compared to the U.S., Canada is moving faster toward cashless retail because of the wide adoption of contactless technology (the ability to wave a credit card or phone to make purchases); a different approach to using cash; and a smaller number of banks and payment processors.

“Forty percent of transactions in Canada are contactless,” said Jeff Guthrie, chief sales and marketing officer at Moneris, one of Canada’s largest payment processors. “It’s easier in Canada compared to the U.S.; we have a handful of very large banks everyone deals with,” he said, adding that a smaller number of acquirers have allowed for contactless technology to be widely offered across point-of-sale terminals across the country.

As Tearsheet reported in May, the U.S. has been slower to take up contactless cards. Three years ago, Chase discontinued the contactless Chase Blink cards it rolled out in 2005; US Bank scrapped contactless cards after an unsuccessful test run a few years ago.

With the widely available option to tap debit and credit cards to buy things, people tap to pay for even the smallest of purchases, said Guthrie. As a result, people even started paying for coffee and donuts this way. Canada has also made a few moves that facilitated the cashless transition for retailers, including the replacement of $1 and $2 bills with coins (the so-called “loonies” and “toonies”) and the abolition of the penny five years ago.

“Once you accumulate a few coins in your pocket, they weigh you down quickly,” said Guthrie. “The idea to tap is very convenient.”

In the U.S., while the idea of banning cash from retail is being tested, it’s far from becoming the norm.

“I think it would take excluding whole groups of our country for retail to go fully cashless,” said Arianne Bennett, co-founder of the Amsterdam Falafelshop, a small chain of restaurants with locations across the U.S. The restaurant tried going cashless but decided to go back to letting customers use cash.

“It disrespects people who don’t have access to forms of electronic payments, bank accounts, etc., basically the middle class to the most poor among us,” she said. Contrast that to Canada, where 99 percent of people have access to bank accounts.

Still, others in the payments industry feel that U.S. retailers will eventually go cashless, but before that, there needs to be a compelling business case for both retailers and customers.

“If you’re going to drive out cash, you need alternatives — one is contactless payments, and the second alternative could be peer-to-peer payments,” said Ron van Wezel, senior analyst at Aite Group, adding that a future U.S. payments ecosystem could see customers using peer-to-peer payments services like Venmo or Zelle for retail purchases.

0 comments on “How Canadian retailers are waging war on cash”

Payments, Power of Payments Podcast

Power of Payments Ep. 14: JPMorgan vs Stripe and Block, CFPB is coming for BNPL, and is LTO a viable BNPL alternative?

  • This week, we talk about JPMorgan’s acquisition of payments firms Renovite, and the CFPB’s recent report on BNPL firms, which suggests that regulation is coming for the sector.
  • We also discuss why lease-to-own, which is another type of installment payment option, has been gaining popularity in recent months.
Ismail Umar | September 23, 2022
Payments

Takeaways from Tearsheet’s Power of Payments conference last week

  • Last week, Tearsheet hosted its inaugural T-POP Conference, focused on payments.
  • Here are the major challenges and opportunities we zeroed in on at the event as we plan for the future of payments.
Zachary Miller | September 21, 2022
Member Exclusive, Payments

‘It’s new branding to what is a very classic industry’: Ramp’s Eric Glyman on B2B BNPL, and how their new offering is different

  • What's the secret sauce behind Ramp's doubling valuation and revenue growth amid a fintech downturn?
  • Eric Glyman, co-founder and CEO of Ramp, spills the beans on his company strategies and what's in the offing.
Sara Khairi | September 13, 2022
Member Exclusive, Payments

Payments Briefing: Does lease-to-own provide a “recession-proof” alternative to BNPL?

  • This week, we explore lease-to-own, an installment payment option that has been gaining popularity in recent months.
  • We also discuss SMBs' increasing reliance on cross-border payments, and the steps that providers can take to serve them better.
Ismail Umar | September 09, 2022
Payments, Power of Payments Podcast

Power of Payments Ep. 13: ‘You need to have a good answer to the question, how do you get to profitability?’ – Rapyd’s Eric Rosenthal

  • Eric Rosenthal, vice president of corporate development, strategy and partnerships at Rapyd, joins host Ismail Umar on this week’s podcast.
  • He talks about how Rapyd caters to businesses of different sizes including major firms like Uber, what American companies can learn from payments firms in Latin America, Asia, and Europe, and how startups in the space should try to deal with the current downturn.
Ismail Umar | September 09, 2022
More Articles