The Customer Effect

Why fintech companies are acting like banks

  • As fintech startups grow their service offerings, some argue fintech companies are acting like banks in their own right.
  • The line between financial services startups and banks is getting blurred due to changes brought about by technology.
close

Email a Friend

Why fintech companies are acting like banks
With the advent of slick bank innovation centers and hip working spaces (one bank's digital innovation factory that Tearsheet reported on earlier this year is an example), banks are acting more like startups. But a move that's getting traction lately is the idea of the fintech startup acting more like a bank, particularly large companies with multiple service offerings. A recent example would be SoFi's application for an industrial loan company charter, a license that allows a nonbank to offer bank-type services. To one venture capitalist, it's not a new trend but one that makes sense for well-resourced players capable of taking on more services. "It's logical that well-funded and successful nonbank institutions get a banking license to better serve customers," said Ryan Gilbert, a partner at Propel Venture Partners. "The team at SoFi is probably as good if not better than most regional banks in the U.S.; we should applaud that, as it's pro-consumer and good for the industry." Gilbert said what's driving the change is the transformation of banking from a brick-and-mortar branch model based on physical assets to a digital-first model where banks become data businesses. "The bulk of the actions are happening on websites or mobile apps, but the future is where banks are invisible," he said. Gilbert added that "invisible banks" will be more open to working with data aggregators to facilitate data-sharing with third-party apps, with JPMorgan's agreement with Finicity being a recent example. Others argue that while startups compete head-to-head with banks, some outrightly resist taking on bank-type services when it's not in their interest. "A lot of fintech companies are staunchly resisting the urge to become banks  -- they don’t offer products that banks offer and instead focus on APIs or fancy graphical user interfaces, or offer consultancy-type services to banking clients," said Chris Khan, project lead at R3, a bank consortium working on distributed ledger technology. Still, Khan suggests many large fintech companies are branding themselves as consumer-focused startups, railing against negative perceptions of big finance brands that bleed customers on fees. "Venmo seems like it's a cool, hip thing, but it’s PayPal with a different user experience [adding friends]," he said. The big brands are also aiming to jump on the cute startup train, with large corporates developing smaller spinoffs to appeal to millennials, like Goldman Sachs' online lender Marcus. "Marcus sounds like a cute hipster bar; it’s less scary," he said. "[The thinking is] if banks can have spinoff companies, they stand a chance of capturing market share." But some startups are seeking to grow their reach by offering financial service hubs for customers through partnerships with incumbent banks, thereby keeping their customer-focused image and working with bigger players when necessary. "In a lot of ways, we aren't that different from a bank, but we don’t take deposits," said Tim Hong, chief marketing officer at personal finance startup MoneyLion. "From our standpoint, we go where the customer tells us -- we work with banks when it's in our interest to partner with them and when it serves customers' needs." Hong wouldn't say whether MoneyLion would move toward taking deposits, but Clarity Money, a personal finance platform that also partners with banks, said it had no intent in moving to the deposit-taking business. "We are not and will never become a bank; it's not the nature of our business," said Colin Kennedy, chief revenue officer for Clarity Money. "Banks are very dependent on fees and proprietary products." Even if startups act like banks, for them, the road to growth is through partnerships. Gilbert said this is the result of a consensus that neither banks nor startups will supplant one another. "In 2017, there's a grudging respect between fintechs and bankers," he said. "Both understand what either is about; neither one is going to disrupt the other, but find ways to work together and rebuild financial services." The blurring of the lines between banks and fintech startups is causing a rethinking of the definition of a bank. Brian Knight, a senior research fellow at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University, said that to regulators, banks are deposit-taking institutions, but a bank doesn't necessarily need to be defined by that. "When we say bank-like, it's not necessarily getting a [bank] charter," said Knight. "When we talk about bank-like, it's about offering a bundle of financial services."  As a result, for some customers, the bank of the future may actually be the fintech startup that they deal with most often. "You could look at it as a social construct," said Khan. "They aren't banks in the traditional sense, but they are banks because they let you store money. It boils down to the construct of what people feel is a bank."

0 comments on “Why fintech companies are acting like banks”

Sponsored, The Customer Effect

Voice of the Customer: How “active listening” drives meaningful consumer engagement

  • Successful bankers act on feedback from their customers in relation to in-person or digital experiences, as consumers hold the key to improving how financial institutions conduct day-to-day business.
  • Today’s consumers have very little patience for financial institutions that do not place them at the center of the customer journey. Ignoring feedback from critical customer journey key points can drastically impede customer acquisition and retention.
Argo | January 19, 2023
Banking, Sponsored, The Customer Effect

How one bank is successfully building deeper customer relationships through digital customer engagement

  • Despite the gains in convenience and capability that digital channels offer, bankers and their customers are missing the relationship aspect of banking. People still want to connect with people.
  • Banks are now shifting their thinking beyond simple “digital transformation” toward “digital customer engagement” and how to leverage the digital channel to support more meaningful customer interactions.
Agent IQ | January 03, 2023
The Customer Effect

The financial state and widening inclusion gap of the LGBTQ+ community

  • A major portion of LGBTQ+ people is currently underserved by traditional financial institutions.
  • The queer community urges the sector to be more inclusive in the marketing and provision of its products and services.
Sara Khairi | December 16, 2022
Sponsored, The Customer Effect

Mobile banking outlook for 2023: Why push notifications are more important than ever

  • Mobile banking usage is quickly growing in popularity as account holders are afforded 24/7 access to their finances and enhanced ease of use.
  • Push notifications enable financial providers to take advantage of this surge by driving account holders to their mobile banking apps and increasing customer engagement.
Larky | December 02, 2022
Sponsored by Visa, The Customer Effect

Holiday travel is around the corner — is it time for a customer experience refresh?

  • New research finds 41% of U.S. adults are planning to travel this holiday season.
  • Nearly three years since the onset of the pandemic, 40% of surveyed travelers reported changing their travel behaviors.
Visa | November 14, 2022
More Articles