The Customer Effect

Striking the right balance between branch and mobile banking

  • Mobile interactions incur a cost of about 10 cents, a small fraction of the $4 cost of a teller or call-agent interaction.
  • U.S. banks would save $11 billion annually if customers’ branch and call-center use declined to the Dutch level.
close

Email a Friend

Striking the right balance between branch and mobile banking

The common mode of thinking pits mobile banking against the traditional bank branch as a zero sum game. Though consumers do appreciate the ease of use and convenience of mobile banking, for the most part, they like to know the branch is there.

Mobile banking is a top strategic priority for most banks, not just because of the good customer response, but also because of the cost reduction associated with it. Each mobile interaction incurs a variable cost of about 10 cents, a small fraction of the $4 cost of a teller or call-agent interaction, according to Customer Loyalty in Retail Banking 2016, a recently published report by Bain and Co.

When comparing the two, both on price and customer satisfaction, mobile is a clear winner. However,  the off-the-cuff conclusion, to gradually shut down most branches, is a false one.

In most countries surveyed, shutting down branches was accompanied with some sort of negative business outcome. Many customer either switched banks after their branch closed or didn’t switch but started using products of other banks.

screenshot-www-bain-com-2016-12-12-09-52-53

How can banks ensure access to tellers while keeping costs down? Some European banks might have the answer.

The Netherlands was one of the first countries to adopt mobile banking and Dutch banks began to reconfigure their branch networks a decade ago. Dutch banks have not completely eliminated the traditional branch, though headcounts are way downs. Instead, they changed the nature of the branch.

ING, for example, has side counters in bookstores and tobacco shops. SNS has franchise arrangements with insurance agents and others. Most customers still have access to a banker in walking or biking distance, but in a streamlined, low-cost format.

Bain and Co. estimate that the 25 U.S. banks would save $11.4 billion annually in aggregate if customers’ branch and call-center use declined to the Dutch level, and the banks reduced headcount accordingly.

These findings are especially important for small or regional banks which might be struggling in an environment of high capital requirements and low interest rates and are looking to cut costs.

0 comments on “Striking the right balance between branch and mobile banking”

The Customer Effect

‘Indian Country has been plagued by systemic red-lining’: Indigenous communities are the most unbanked in the U.S.

  • Indigenous people in the U.S. and Canada continue to face institutional discrimination in their banking experiences.
  • Indigenous-owned banks and enterprises are paving a path for economic autonomy and prosperity for their communities.
Rimal Farrukh | February 09, 2021
The Customer Effect

‘They blamed me’: Banks aren’t doing enough to service those suffering from mental health issues

  • Mental health related services remain largely under-represented in fintech and banking spaces.
  • Empathy training for customer service experiences and accessible apps can help support people with mental health problems manage their money.
Rimal Farrukh | January 26, 2021
Member Exclusive, The Customer Effect

Citizens Bank’s Beth Johnson: ‘Personal interaction remains important to customers’

  • What bank clients expect from their institutions is changing, according a new Bank Experience Survey.
  • Citizens Bank CXO Beth Johnson joins us to discuss the findings of the research and how it's impacting banking today and in the future.
Zachary Miller | August 11, 2020
Member Exclusive, The Customer Effect

With deposit volume growing 705% in April, MANTL raises $19 million

  • MANTL, which helps banks open digital accounts, has experienced strong growth during the pandemic.
  • The company is also announcing an additional fundraising.
Zachary Miller | July 16, 2020
The Customer Effect

Now under the Linux Foundation, the Fintech Open Source Foundation wants to accelerate software development across financial services

  • FINOS runs 11 programs driven by more than 30 financial services organizations and technology members.
  • Aligning with Linux, the group will have more resources and reach to encourage open source software development.
Zoe Murphy | April 28, 2020
More Articles