The Customer Effect

Can better products and lending practices heal marketplace lending’s hangover?

  • Marketplace lenders are suffering from a steep decline in investor demand.
  • Industry analysts are bullish long term if the platforms can develop compelling products for investors.
close

Email a Friend

Can better products and lending practices heal marketplace lending’s hangover?
The tide is waning for marketplace lending. As Warren Buffet once said, we are now about to see who has been swimming naked.  However, contrary to panicked media reports, the industry is not in danger. It is just dealing with a hangover. Marketplace lenders experienced incredible growth since 2010, with annual origination volumes on Lending Club and Prosper – the 2 largest marketplace lenders -- rising from $153 million in 2010 to over $12 billion in 2015. In 2016, the trend reversed. For Lending Club, total originations for Q2 2016 came in at $1.96 billion, down from a peak of $2.75 billion in Q1. In 2Q15, Prosper reported a steep decline of over 50% in originations compared to same period a year before. Marketplace lenders are trying to explain the change. “The decreases above are the result of a number of our largest investors that have paused or significantly reduced their purchases of whole loans through Prosper’s marketplace,” the company stated in its recent quarterly report. It promised to take steps to increase available capital by increasing the interest rates on loans, launching a new line of asset management products and improving the retail investor experience. The hype can be clearly seen in PwC’s DeNovo quarterly report, which tracks fintech trends. Marketplace lending was the top trend for the first three quarters in 2015, but dropped to the second-largest trend in 4Q15. In 1Q16, the industry did not even make the top 10. “Back in late 2015 everyone was getting into the space, and there was too much optimism” said James Wu, founder and CEO of Monja, a marketplace lending analytics company. Now, he adds, smarter investors are looking at data more carefully and can generate better returns. “From our own analysis, we see some of the returns for platforms are better than they have been in the last 24 months. 2015 was a great year for platforms, but from an investment perspective, the returns were low.” According to Wu, an excess of funding in 2015 caused marketplace lenders to desperately look to expand their borrower base, venturing into lower tiers of credit, pushed by aggressive marketing techniques like direct mailing. The repercussions of such action are now visible with a rise in delinquencies and a damning report from Moody’s questioning the viability of the asset class. “Investor overreacted to that news,” said Wu, adding that the 2015 vintages are hurting current performance, overshadowing newer and better vintages that will generate long term growth and returns for investors. Though each platform comes with a built in set of analytics tools that allow investors to select loans according to their risk appetite, third party analytics companies, such as Monja or Orchard, can give investors the ability to work across multiple platforms and provide deeper insight into the sources of excess returns. Such strategies are of course harder than dumping money into all platforms as some investors did a year ago. Unlike other sources of capital, securitizations of marketplace loans are trending upwards, topping $1.7 billion according to PeerIQ, and will probably become a more substantial source of capital for marketplace lenders. This, however, is a far cry from marketplace lending's P2P origins. Marketplace lenders are at a crossroads. The resulting shakeout, however, might prove to be beneficial to the market. “Investors are getting more realistic about returns, and platforms are getting more realistic about what they can get away with. They need to come back and offer products that are compelling for investors,” Wu concluded.

0 comments on “Can better products and lending practices heal marketplace lending’s hangover?”

The Customer Effect

The White House is proposing an increase in the capital gains tax. What will non-white groups gain?

  • The White House is proposing a hike in capital gains tax as part of a deficit reduction plan.
  • The taxation system in America needs another look, so far the balance has been tipped in the favor of investors and white households. Will the capital gains tax rebalance the scales?
Rabab Ahsan | March 15, 2023
The Customer Effect

Americans think financial literacy can help them cope with the cost of living

  • Consumer prices are rising and the cost of everyday goods is expected to remain volatile.
  • With the frequent ups and downs in the economy, consumers are starting to bank on financial literacy to help them weather the storm.
Rabab Ahsan | March 02, 2023
The Customer Effect

Consumers are relying more on credit in this bad economy

  • Due to economic headwinds, people are turning to credit to make ends meet.
  • What will this upswing mean for issuers in the future?
Rabab Ahsan | February 24, 2023
The Customer Effect

How are Americans coping with their financial burnout?

  • Americans are feeling financially overwhelmed due to sustained inflation and slow economic growth.
  • Many consumers are now putting a greater emphasis on financial well-being, and have increased their reliance on digital banking tools.
Sara Khairi | February 13, 2023
The Customer Effect

With high inflation, are savings out of the picture for American consumers?

  • Inflation has been affecting saving habits across the board as consumers have to spend more to afford basic necessities.
  • Given the turbulence of the past few years, paying off debt has been ranking high on the list of savings priorities for most Americans.
Rabab Ahsan | February 08, 2023
More Articles