4 charts, Member Exclusive

How the pandemic has accelerated the demise of credit cards, in 4 charts

  • U.S. consumers are slashing their credit card use, particularly Millennials and Gen Z.
  • The declining popularity of credit cards among young shoppers could be an early sign of a permanent shift in consumer preferences.
close

Email a Friend

How the pandemic has accelerated the demise of credit cards, in 4 charts

The credit card has a long-standing relationship with the American consumer. It’s certainly come a long way since the launch of Diners Club — the world’s first consumer-facing credit card company — in 1950, and American Express’ issuance of the world’s first plastic card in 1959.

But after decades of dominance in the U.S., the credit card may finally be losing its hold over American finance. The move away from credit cards seems to have accelerated over the last year and a half, thanks largely to (you guessed it) the pandemic and the resulting economic uncertainty, as well as the growing popularity of alternative payment options such as Buy Now, Pay Later.

The credit card has a long-standing relationship with the American consumer. It’s certainly come a long way since the launch of Diners Club — the world’s first consumer-facing credit card company — in 1950, and American Express’ issuance of the world’s first plastic card in 1959.

But after decades of dominance in the U.S., the credit card may finally be losing its hold over American finance. The move away from credit cards seems to have accelerated over the last year and a half, thanks largely to (you guessed it) the pandemic and the resulting economic uncertainty, as well as the growing popularity of alternative payment options such as Buy Now, Pay Later.

Customer satisfaction with credit card issuers has seen a visible decline this year, owing to increasing financial uncertainty, combined with factors such as high interest rates, shrinking credit limits, and misdirected rewards programs. Credit card issuers are struggling to meet the rapidly evolving expectations of customers through the pandemic.

“The industry missed the mark on supporting customers’ changing needs when many were facing significant financial challenges,” said John Cabell, director of banking and payments intelligence at J.D. Power. “Whether through tightening credit limits at the very moment when customers were most reliant on their cards for short-term funding, or through a lack of customer service accessibility, credit card issuers experienced declines in overall satisfaction, trust, and brand perception this year.”


This content is available exclusively to Tearsheet Outlier members.

Tearsheet Outlier information and signup Missing out? Subscribe today and you’ll receive unlimited access to all Tearsheet content, original research, exclusive webinars and events, member-only newsletters from Tearsheet editors and reporters and much more. Join Outlier now — only $49/mo. Already an Outlier member? Sign in to your account

0 comments on “How the pandemic has accelerated the demise of credit cards, in 4 charts”

Lending, Member Exclusive

Lending Briefing: Customers would share data to improve their creditworthiness

  • Over 75% consumers believe that a credit score shouldn’t be the only determinant for loan eligibility.
  • In the absence of lending products that fit their needs, consumers are turning to fintechs and their families to avoid predatory loans or rejections.
Rabab Ahsan | December 07, 2022
Data Snacks, Member Exclusive

Data Snack: The dawn of bank branch 2.0?

  • The ‘death of the branch’ saga was all the rage back in 2020.
  • But now, with back-to-routine vibes emerging, it’s time to re-evaluate the role of a bank branch.
Rivka Abramson | December 05, 2022
Data Snacks, Member Exclusive

Data Snack: Millennial retail traders rise during the bear market

  • Millennials opened 46% of all new retail trading accounts in the first half of 2022, according to DriveWealth’s Global Investor Report.
  • The ability to invest with small dollar amounts was the most frequently cited motivator to start investing.
Lindi Miti | December 01, 2022
Green Finance, Member Exclusive

Green Finance Briefing: The stroll to zero – finance has a long way to go

  • At COP27, there were no commitments to phase down or reduce fossil fuel use in the final overarching deal, and there was no breakthrough in the rules of finance either.
  • GFANZ faces a serious question: what is the purpose of a net-zero alliance when members are allowed to continue investing in fossil fuel expansion?
Iulia Ciutina | November 30, 2022
Embedded Finance, Member Exclusive

Embedded Briefing: SMB servicing presents strong potential for embedded finance

  • Across the US, UK, and Europe, the SMB embedded finance market presents a $110 billion opportunity.
  • SMBs are demanding easier access to capital, simplified financial management, and card issuing capabilities.
Subboh Jaffery | November 29, 2022
More Articles