Green Finance

Transparency is important but not enough for a greener financial system

  • Despite being an important step, transparency around climate impacts is not enough to push investments in the green sector.
  • The financial sector needs support to create a stronger ecosystem of environmentally friendly assets that can absorb large amounts of capital.
close

Email a Friend

Transparency is important but not enough for a greener financial system

The financial sector is facing increasing pressure to reduce its support for the carbon-intensive sector, with banks’ lending practices getting more attention. 

The main response from government bodies and regulators is to upgrade financial disclosure requirements to include climate risks and impacts. This aims to increase investors’ responsibility by making them report on the climate impacts of their investment portfolios. 

However, the problem is much larger and more complex to solve than just shining a light on current practices. 

While enhanced disclosures are an important step towards a sustainable economy, they are insufficient to fuel a mass diversion of capital towards the clean energy sector given the current financial system’s infrastructure. The idea that once we can see where the money is going, we can redirect it to sustainable portfolios may not be entirely feasible. 

Even in today’s opaque environment there is increasing uncertainty over the future demand for fossil fuel investments, while appetite is growing for companies with long-term sustainability goals. The ESG market has grown rapidly, with a third of the total $1.5 trillion global green bond market issued just this year, according to the Climate Bonds Initiative.

However, the issue with moving capital away from fossil fuels and towards clean energy is that the green investments market is still relatively small with low liquidity. 

Fossil fuels represent a long-standing and highly consolidated industry, having taken in large and stable investments over the past few decades. Only in the five years after the Paris Agreement, it’s been estimated that 60 of the world’s largest commercial and investment banks have collectively invested $3.8 trillion into fossil fuels.

In contrast, the renewable sector is young and fragmented. Despite its rapid growth over the past decade, it’s still characterized by many small participants, often operating in only one market. This results in lower revenues and market capitalization, limiting renewables’ ability to attract investment. 

SPONSOR

The green investment arena is simply not big enough to absorb the capital that needs to be diverted away from industries that damage the environment. 

And even if it were, switching from one to the other is not a clear cut environmentally friendly play. There are issues to be considered around the impact of divesting from fossil fuel industries. Even if an investment fund sells its ‘dirty’ assets, someone is purchasing it on the other end – could be a buyer with lower sustainability targets or who doesn’t have to be as transparent about their investments.   

Therefore, a downside of increased transparency for regulated entities could be that ownership will simply move away from public view, which is not necessarily a long-term, sustainable strategy.  

Moreover, the growing market for environmental investments is currently unregulated. Ratings agencies such as S&P Global or Morningstar issue “green” ratings on stocks and bonds, but these come without any regulatory checks. 

This problem is only now being addressed by the International Organization of Securities Commissions, which includes watchdogs from the US, Europe, Asia and Latin America. The organization recently issued some recommendations for its members in an effort to shine light on how ESG ratings are compiled and help combat greenwashing. 

But governments and regulatory bodies have a bigger part to play beyond regulating disclosures requirements and ratings. Climate and energy policy design should consider innovation in low-carbon financing and investor preferences, including their levels of risk appetite and available capital, to create a stronger ecosystem for green assets.

Overall, perhaps the bigger focus should be on expanding the financial sector and bringing clean energy investing into the mainstream. If sustainable portfolios become more attractive to investors, capital will follow. 

0 comments on “Transparency is important but not enough for a greener financial system”

Outlier OpinionsMakers

Green Finance, Member Exclusive

Green Finance Briefing: What’s a sustainable business strategy in banking?

  • Executives need to start thinking of how to create and execute a sustainability strategy as the economy transitions to a carbon-neutral future.
  • At Tearsheet's Banking on the Planet conference, speakers outlined how financial companies can start on their sustainability journeys – it's all about education, collaboration and transparency.
Iulia Ciutina | August 05, 2022
Green Finance

Big banks are financing the fossil fuel industry – and it’s time consumers know it’s with their money

  • JPMorgan Chase invested $382 billion in the fossil fuel industry between 2016 and 2021.
  • Ando Money provides an alternative place for consumers to bank, where their money is always used to finance green projects.
Rabab Ahsan | August 02, 2022
Announcement, Green Finance

Banking on the Planet Conference 2022: All session videos

  • Tearsheet’s inaugural Banking on the Planet Conference brings together leaders from the banks set out to make a difference, and the fintechs and technology providers bringing us closer to a net zero future.
  • Here are the full videos from the sessions we held on July 26, 2022.
Shabih Rao | July 29, 2022
Green Finance, Member Exclusive

Green Finance Briefing: Burning for change

  • The heat wave that hit Europe proves once more the urgency of the climate crisis, and that we all need to collectively and proactively work towards investing in solutions.
  • Join us on Tuesday, July 26 at our Banking on the Planet conference, where we'll discuss how the banking and finance industry can start its sustainability journey.
Iulia Ciutina | July 22, 2022
Green Finance, Member Exclusive

It’s digital, but is it green? The effects of payments on the environment, in 4 charts

  • Payments won't be green until we tackle the emissions inherent to the smartphone industry
  • In 2021 the e-waste generated globally weighed as much as the Great Wall of China.
Rabab Ahsan | July 19, 2022
More Articles