Confessions

‘Sick and tired of no one innovating’: Confessions of a financial tech entrepreneur

  • Banks are increasingly putting money and resources behind startups that develop products for the underserved.
  • Some startup entrepreneurs feel banks are pushing them into the 'inclusion' space to keep them away from more profitable high-income customers.
‘Sick and tired of no one innovating’: Confessions of a financial tech entrepreneur

Sunshine is the best disinfectant: We trade anonymity for honesty to get an unvarnished look at the people, processes and problems inside the industry.

It can be hard to keep track of all the apps that help users save money or get access to credit. Financial technology entrepreneurs have an impressive track record of developing products for underserved, low-income populations. Big banks are increasingly offering startups big money and advice to build these products. But in the startup sphere, some feel pushed by the banks to work on products for lower-income customers. To them, this lets the banks to appear like they’re giving back, while keeping the startups out of the more profitable high-income customer segments.

For the latest in our Confessions series, we spoke to a startup entrepreneur with considerable experience in the banking sector. Here are the excerpts, edited for clarity.

Big banks are supporting startups working on products for poor, underserved populations. Do you think this is because they actually care?
The financial inclusion thing is ominous. It’s because the banks have high fixed costs and aren’t able to reduce them. We do all the things they don’t want to do, picking up the pennies in front of the steamroller. But don’t come into the high earning area.

So banks are making more money off of high-income customers, and are pushing the startups to take the lower income ones they don’t want?
They would much rather get their tax breaks and give to charity and say they’re doing good for the country than get their hands dirty with a bunch of very subprime demographics. The fintech guys have to go to high risk. If you’re a bank, you can cherry-pick all the rich people and not have as many defaults in a downturn.

Do you have to work with a bank to be successful in the startup world?
Really, there’s no getting out of it. Even if you’re a money transmitter you still need a bank account — you still need to hold your money at a bank. If you’re doing something with cards, you have to have a card issuer and the card issuer has to be a bank and a member of Visa and Mastercard if you use them as well.

What about accelerators and incubator programs where the banks mentor startups. Doesn’t that show their goodwill?
They just steal your ideas. They’re not doing it for the good of their soul. They’re doing it to take a chunk and or steal the idea as you build it and do it themselves.

Are there areas where startups can get into that banks aren’t addressing?
You see things like student loans like SoFi. They realized that banks didn’t understand the difference between a Harvard grad and a whatever local college grad. They’ve managed to get into a spot where the banks are too lazy to even sift through the data.

If it’s so hard to get your product to market, what’s the objective of a startup entrepreneur? Is it just to cash in when you’re acquired by a bank?
If you’re looking to make a little bit of money quick, it’s probably not a bad play, but if you’re actually looking for any kind of change in the world, and you believe in that, it’s not a good move. That’s the reason why people go into this, and I believe I’m one of them. I am bored and sick and tired of no one innovating in the space.

Confessions

Confessions of a former trader: Incentives at banks are misaligned

  • Banks have investment millions in fintech, but implementing it is a long-term project since they're still plagued with legacy infrastructure
  • Goldman Sachs' Marcus is "probably able" to win in the short term but might stumble 10 years out if its targeted millennials don't grow their wealth
Tanaya Macheel | May 02, 2018
Confessions

‘Women are not a target market’: Confessions of a former finance marketer

  • There’s no shortage of headlines and reports about how companies fall short in marketing to women
  • Unless research comes out specifying what about the marketing isn't working, the problem is that women are treated as a niche
Tanaya Macheel | March 09, 2018
Confessions

‘Banks can’t attract the talent they want or need’: Confessions of a banking startup analyst

  • "The origination number alone is not enough information to say if they're doing a good job."
  • "For an engineer, the pay is generally competitive, but the working environment and the types of problems they get to solve absolutely aren’t."
Tanaya Macheel | December 19, 2017
Confessions

Confessions of a finance PR: Finance companies are led by people who aren’t tech savvy and will never be

  • Banks and startups might be embracing each other now, but they're still not exactly on the same page and definitely still operating on uneven fields.
  • Banks "should be focusing on the 'fin' targets and less on the 'tech' portion when it comes to media."
Tanaya Macheel | July 05, 2017
Confessions

Confessions of a fintech VC: No one is using fintech outside Venmo

  • Fintech startups may be friendly with banks now, but it hasn't made it to the big leagues yet.
  • In a sense, banks are true fintech companies; in another, banks and startups will still divide and conquer different customers.
Tanaya Macheel | April 03, 2017
More Articles