Citi, Morgan Stanley, BofA, and Goldman Sachs’ Q2 results: All you need to know
- Here's a detailed rundown of the second installment of big bank earnings last week for Q2 2023.
- Morgan Stanley's wealth management unit saw its net revenue climb 16% to $6.7 billion for the second quarter, and it gained nearly $90 billion in new assets.
Welcome to the 10-Q newsletter
The 10-Q newsletter is part of the Tearsheet Pro subscription.
10-Q provides insight and market analysis into the moves of top banking and fintech stocks over the past week. In your inbox every Friday.
In today's edition:
Last week we covered:
Citi, Morgan Stanley, BofA, and Goldman Sachs' Q2 results: All you need to know
Citi, Morgan Stanley, BofA, and Goldman Sachs' Q2 results: All you need to know
Here's our rundown of the second installment of big bank earnings last week.
by SARA KHAIRI
CITI: Net income dropped like a stone
Citi's profit took a hit in the second quarter and was at odds with higher profits reported by peers JPMorgan Chase and Wells Fargo last to last Friday.
For the second quarter ending 30 June, Citigroup reported:
- Net income fell 36% to $2.9 billion, or $1.33 per share, from $4.5 billion, or $2.19 per share, last year
- Revenue fell 1% from a year ago and came in at $19.4 billion for the quarter
- Total allowance for credit losses on loans was $17.5 billion at quarter end compared to $16 billion at the end of the prior year period
The slump in Citi's net income was primarily driven by higher expenses, higher cost of credit, and lower revenue. Higher costs for layoffs and increased provisions for credit losses also played their part in impacting profits. Revenue decreased sharply on account of the decline in markets and investment banking businesses amid slowing client activity. However, revenue from personal banking and wealth management increased 6% in the quarter to $6.4 billion partly fueled by loan income.
“Markets revenues were down from a strong second quarter last year, as clients stood on the sidelines starting in April while the U.S. debt limit played out,” said Jane Fraser, Citi's CEO. “In banking, the long-awaited rebound in Investment Banking has yet to materialize, making for a disappointing quarter.”
Shares of Citigroup tumbled 4% last to last Friday.
MORGAN STANLEY: Wealth Management saved the day yet again
Earnings driven by the wealth management unit were Morgan Stanley's saving grace for the second quarter.
Morgan Stanley reported:
- Net income decreased 13% from a year ago to $2.18 billion, or $1.24 a share, compared with net income of $2.5 billion, or $1.39 per diluted share for the same period a year ago
- Revenue increased 2% to $13.46 billion from $13.1 billion a year ago
- Provision for credit losses was $161 million from $101 million in Q2'22
The jump in provisions for credit losses was primarily driven by credit deteriorations in the commercial real estate sector as well as slow growth across the portfolio. On the bright side, second-quarter wealth management revenue rose 16% to $6.66 billion on higher interest income, compared with $5.7 billion from a year ago.
"The Firm delivered solid results in a challenging market environment. The quarter started with macroeconomic uncertainties and subdued client activity but ended with a more constructive tone," said James Gorman, CEO of Morgan Stanley. "Consistent with our strategy, we continued to attract client assets – Wealth and Investment Management added $100 billion in net new assets, bringing in over $200 billion year-to-date."
Morgan Stanley shares climbed more than 6% following the earnings results on Tuesday.
BANK OF AMERICA: Significant gains in Trading and Investment Banking
Bank of America delivered better-than-expected results in the second quarter riding high on strong gains in the investment banking business.
Bank of America reported:
- Net income rose 19% to $7.4 billion, or $0.88 per diluted share, compared to $6.2 billion, or $0.73 per diluted share for Q2'22
- Revenue increased 11% to $25.2 billion
- Provision for credit losses was $1.1 billion, a significant increase from $602 million a year ago
The average deposit balances for the bank declined by 7% to $1.9 trillion. Recently, the firm was fined $250 million by US federal regulators for allegedly hurting customers by double-dipping on fees, withholding credit card rewards, and opening fake accounts. This number will also add up to the bank's expenses for the next quarter. However, Bank of America's Q2 results continued to benefit from higher rates on consumer loans. The investment banking sector also saw gains with net income jumping as much as 76% to $2.7 billion, fueled by higher interest payments and leasing revenue.
"We continue to see a healthy US economy that is growing at a slower pace, with a resilient job market," said Brian Moynihan, CEO of Bank of America. "All businesses performed well and we saw improved market shares, particularly in our Sales and Trading and Investment Banking businesses."
Bank of America shares climbed more than 4% after the earnings release on Tuesday.
GOLDMAN SACHS: Earnings hit rock bottom
While Citigroup and Morgan Stanley also saw their profit decline, Goldman reported the largest drop among its peers on Wednesday.
Goldman Sachs reported:
- Net income fell 58% to $1.22 billion, or $3.08 a share, compared with $7.73 for the second quarter of 2022
- Revenue fell 8% to $10.9 billion from $11.8 billion in Q2'22
- Provision for credit losses was at $615 million
Goldman faced a strong blow in net income due to dealmaking and trading grappling with the macroeconomic climate and eventually drying up -- the major revenue driver for the bank. The firm also incurred $504 million in losses related to the fintech unit GreenSky. Furthermore, the firm suffered a loss from its consumer and real estate businesses, which added $485 million to the damage.
“Our results were impacted by the challenging macro environment and in particular headwinds facing our specific mix of businesses,” said David Solomon, CEO of Goldman Sachs. “Activity levels in many areas of investment banking hover near decade-long lows and clients largely maintained a risk-off posture over the course of the quarter.”
Shares of the bank were trading nearly 0.9% higher following the earnings call on Wednesday.
The stock market saw a mix of losses and gains last week
Upstart (UPST) - up 17% to $55.39 per share
- A better-than-expected inflation report last week showing that inflation may be coming down continued to benefit the Upstart stock this week.
- Additionally, a pause in rate hikes and long-term funding deals seem to work in favor of the stock. While many think that the Federal Reserve is nearly done with its federal funds rate hikes, it's not certain as the Fed indicated that rates may rise again if inflation proves to be stickier.
Morgan Stanley (MS) - up 9% to $93.80 per share
- Shares of Morgan Stanley rose after the bank released its Q2 earnings.
- The profit surpassed analysts' estimates as its wealth management business supported its overall earnings in the second quarter, and executives expressed optimism about the economic environment.
- The wealth management unit's net revenue climbed 16% to $6.7 billion for the quarter, and it gained nearly $90 billion in new assets.
Wells Fargo (WFC) - up 8% to $47.13 per share
- Wells Fargo Q2 earnings benefited from strong net interest income.
- The bank’s net interest income jumped 29% to $13.16 billion. The earnings in the consumer and small business banking division also increased reaching $6.6 billion, a 19% rise compared to the previous year.
Tweet of the week
Just look at the charts
This week's reads
Capital One’s company materials show that the allowance for losses in its credit card portfolio was just under $11 billion, representing a 7.7% ratio, up from the 6.7% seen a year ago — but below the double digits seen at the end of 2020. Drilling down into the domestic card business, per the company results for the second quarter ending June 30, the 30-day performing delinquency rate was 3.7% in the most recent period, up from 2.4% last year, even as purchase volumes in the quarter rose 11% to more than $154 billion.
On Thursday the Federal Reserve launched the first phase of an instant payment infrastructure called FedNow Service that promises to make the option of safe, real-time payments much more widely available at large and small US financial institutions. FedNow launched with only 35 banks and credit unions live on the network.
Coinbase Borrow, a program that allowed customers to receive fiat loans of up to $1 million against as much as 30% of their bitcoin holdings, will be shutting down over the coming months as the company focuses its resources on products that “customers care about most". Customers who hold loans through the program will have until November 20, 2023, to pay back any outstanding loan balances.
America’s consumer watchdog says bank mergers are set to become much tougher to pull off. CFPB Director Rohit Chopra said lenders should expect more scrutiny into mergers following this year’s banking crisis. It was noted that Chopra’s tone contrasts with other regulators, such as U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen, who have recently shown more enthusiasm for deals to help the regional banking sector, plagued by historic collapses this year.