Member Exclusive

Research: More than half of the industry believes challenger banks won’t be competitive with commercial banks

  • Tearsheet asked professionals what they thought of challenger banks.
  • 57.2 percent of respondents believe challenger banks are overhyped.
close

Email a Friend

Research: More than half of the industry believes challenger banks won’t be competitive with commercial banks

A big chunk of financial and fintech industry insiders don't see challenger banks as making a big dent in incumbent consumer banking. And when it comes to commercial banking, professionals are less impressed.

More than half of the industry insiders polled by Tearsheet don't think challenger banks offerings will be competitive with incumbent commercial banks within 3 to 10 years.

Interestingly, Tearsheet asked 172 financial and fintech industry professionals to rank challenger banks in order of their competitiveness to commercial banks on a scale from 1 to 5, with 5 being the highest. While no individual upstart bank scored higher than 2.18 (Revolut, Azlo and Novo), respondents believe challenger banks are more competitive as a whole over a ten year period (2.36). That may point to an expectation that there will be new players entering the field.

Revolut

Common to many challenger banks, Revolut uses a freemium business model in which it gives a way a free, basic checking account and charges for extras. One of the premium offerings of the UK-based startup is a business account. Revolut continues to roll out new functionality for its business customers, like an expense management tool, making it the highest ranking challenger bank by survey respondents.

N26

N26 is one of the largest challenger banks in terms of users. Like Revolut, it also uses a freemium model. Targeting freelancers, the Berlin-based challenger gives business account holders a Mastercard debit card and some cash back on its usage. Its business offering isn't rated as highly as some of the other challenger banks in the space.

Monzo

Monzo is moving slowly into offering a full-blown business account as it tests things out. The company said it intends to introduce a business account that's more attuned to its customer base's needs, rather than just launch a generic type of account. Without a full release, Monzo ranked as the weakest competitor for business banking among challengers (1.64 over three years and 1.82 over ten).

Monese

Having surpassed the 1 million customer mark earlier in 2019, Monese is working on improving its business accounts. The company partnered with iwoca to offer credit to businesses that qualify. Monese ranked in the middle of the pack as part of Tearsheet's survey on competitiveness for commercial banking business.

Azlo

Unlike Revolut, Monzo, Monese, and N26, Azlo doesn't offer a consumer banking option. With a focus on business accounts, the BBVA-owned challenger bank offers FDIC-backed accounts, financial management tools, and free payments using BBVA infrastructure. Azlo is rated one of the top challengers by survey respondents.

Novo

Novo is also a challenger solely focused on business customers. Novo has been rolling out integrations with many of the popular technology platforms used by SMBs in the U.S. Novo offers no-fee accounts and perks and was also ranked highly by Tearsheet's research panel.

Axos

Axos Bank promotes its own brand as well as functioning as a sponsor bank for other digital offerings. N26's US bank brand was built on top of Axos, for example. Axos has its own federal banking charter and offers small business savings and checking accounts, loans, as well as personal accounts. It doesn't rank particularly high in our survey.

0 comments on “Research: More than half of the industry believes challenger banks won’t be competitive with commercial banks”

10-Q, Member Exclusive

Robinhood unveils a 5% APY for Gold members, but how will users respond?

  • Robinhood's recent move to challenge traditional banks includes its increased savings offering, a 5.0% APY for Robinhood Gold Members. 
  • The stock trading platform appears to be in a precarious balancing act, grappling with the escalation of deposit strategies while facing a decline in both transactions and monthly active users.
Sara Khairi | November 20, 2023
10-Q, Member Exclusive

Q1’24 affirms Affirm’s upswing in BNPL

  • Affirm's quarterly results indicate that back-to-back enterprise collaborations in conjunction with collective strategies are eventually winning out keeping the firm on course.
  • Going forward the BNPL provider intends to focus on continuing to invest in risk management, technology, and product development.
Sara Khairi | November 13, 2023
10-Q, Member Exclusive

Q3: The PayPal story isn’t over

  • PayPal saw improved earnings in the third quarter compared to the previous one.
  • Chriss answered some of the burning questions and gave a bit more color on what firm assets could require more work to turn around than he thought.
Sara Khairi | November 06, 2023
10-Q, Member Exclusive

Ted Pick is Morgan Stanley’s new leader. Where does it go from here? 

  • The question, 'Who will succeed James Gorman at Morgan Stanley?', that echoed in Wall Street's nooks and crannies has finally been answered.
  • The present and incoming CEOs might have different management styles. What they both share, however, is a shrinking economy and growing macroeconomic pressures at the time of assuming control.
Sara Khairi | October 30, 2023
10-Q, Member Exclusive

It’s complicated: Big banks have a love-hate relationship with high interest rates

  •  Although it's a new season, things seem pretty much the same as the last quarter for big banks – except that the figures and their impacts have heightened.
  • The common underlying theme in Q3 was increased write-offs – but it's still raining profits for (most of the) big banks.
Sara Khairi | October 23, 2023
More Articles